Voice Goals for Non-Binary People
On this page
Most voice resources, this site's procedure pages included, describe a voice travelling from one end to the other. Many non-binary and genderfluid people are after something else. Some want listeners to stop placing them at all. Some want to switch registers between work and friends. Others want to move partway, away from how they are read now without arriving at the other end.
The tools available for those goals differ most in one respect, whether you can undo them. Training can be changed or dropped at any point. Testosterone and surgery cannot. For a goal built on flexibility, that difference matters more than any other on this page.
Neutral, flexible, or a direction with a limit
It helps to work out which of these you are after before you talk to anyone, because they lead to different plans.
A neutral voice is one listeners do not confidently place. The loose bands usually quoted for adult speaking pitch overlap at roughly 165 to 180 Hz (see fundamental frequency), and a voice averaging there can be heard either way. What tips it is everything else: resonance, intonation, vocal weight and small habits of speech. A neutral voice is usually a balance of those, not a single number.
A flexible voice is two or more voices you can switch between, the way some people move between accents. That is a trained skill, and it is more work to keep up than a single voice, because each mode needs its own practice.
A direction with a limit is the goal people are often least sure how to say out loud: lighter than now but not feminine, or deeper than now but not male. It is a common goal and a reasonable one.
What training does for these goals
Training is the best-suited tool for all three, because nothing it builds is permanent. A speech-language pathologist can work on resonance and intonation in both directions, set more than one target, and practise the switch itself rather than only the end points. Most of what makes a voice sound neutral is in the parts training changes.
If you want a flexible voice, tell the therapist at the first appointment, not the fifth. Some programmes are built around a single target, and a therapist who knows from the start can plan sessions around two. Working with a voice therapist has questions to ask at the first appointment, including how much of their work is with non-binary clients.
Why surgery narrows your options
Every voice operation moves the range one way and closes off part of the other.
A glottoplasty raises the pitch floor, and the low notes do not come back. After it, you can still darken your resonance and slow your intonation, but you cannot reach the pitches you used to, so a voice that relied on dropping into a lower register loses that half. Cricothyroid approximation raises pitch by stretching the folds, and part of the rise commonly relaxes over the first year or so, so a result that starts in the middle may not stay there. Relaxation thyroplasty lowers pitch and costs some of the top.
Some surgeons will aim for a smaller rise if you ask, for instance by making a shorter web. How precisely anyone can hit a middle target is limited, since the final pitch depends on healing as much as on the stitch. Ask a surgeon directly what they would do differently for a neutral goal, and whether they have done it before.
A tracheal shave is the exception. It changes how the throat looks and, in most people, leaves the voice alone. Plenty of non-binary people want that and nothing else.
Low-dose testosterone and the voice
Many non-binary people consider testosterone at a low dose, or for a limited time, to get some changes and not others. The voice is where that plan most often comes unstuck, and the reason is timing. Voice changes usually start within the first few months, before slower effects such as facial hair or muscle have settled, so by the time you know whether you like the rest, part of the voice change has already happened and will not reverse. A low dose slows that; it does not reliably stop it.
The drop also affects the top of the range. Notes that used to be easy, including falsetto, often become unreliable. If part of your goal is to move up into a lighter voice some days, that gets harder on testosterone, though resonance and intonation can still be lightened by training.
A few people I have known practised a lower, heavier voice with a therapist before starting, to find out how it felt to be heard that way. It does not predict where testosterone will land, but it tells you something about whether you want to go there. The dose and the pace are for you and your prescriber to decide, and testosterone and your voice covers the timeline.
Explaining the goal so it gets heard
Most training programmes and surgical outcome scales are built around two directions, and clinicians used to them will often translate a non-binary goal into the nearer one unless it is pinned down. In the consultations I have sat in on, the goals that survived were described as outcomes rather than identities.
A few ways to do that:
- Bring recordings. Two or three voices, from anyone, that sound like what you want. A therapist can hear resonance and intonation in a clip far faster than they can work them out from a description.
- Name situations. "On a work call I want to stop being called sir or madam" gives a therapist something to aim at and a way to tell whether it is working.
- Say which way you would rather err. If the voice has to land a little to one side, which side is easier to live with? A surgeon can aim short and add later, but cannot take back a rise that overshoots.
- Say what you want to keep. Singing, shouting across a field, a low laugh. A surgeon needs to know which parts of the range you would miss.
For surgery, ask the surgeon what pitch they would aim for, in hertz or semitones, and what they expect you to lose. If the letter writer is new to non-binary patients, ask them to state the goal plainly rather than recasting it as a feminine or masculine one. Letters of support covers what surgeons look for in them.
Funding is not usually decided on identity. Insurers and public systems work from diagnosis and procedure codes, and a well-documented non-binary goal is fundable on the same terms as any other, which often means as rarely. Insurance and funding has the detail.
Not sure whether you need surgery?
The Start Here guide explains what pitch, resonance and training each change, and where surgery fits once you’ve found your ceiling.
start here →